top of page

Camouflage and Autism (3): Beyond Masking: Practical Strategies

Oct 15
10 min read

Updated: Oct 15


The first two posts in this series explored camouflage from two different angles: what it is and why autistic people may use it, and the fact that adapting our behaviour to fit social expectations is by no means an exclusively autistic phenomenon. This post moves from understanding camouflage to something more practical: how can autistic people learn to navigate a social world that may not come naturally to them – without reducing that learning to “masking”?


The strategies discussed here come from autistic individuals diagnosed in childhood who have found ways of building fulfilling, meaningful lives not by making "autistic identity" the core of their existence, but by understanding themselves, recognising their needs and finding ways to function in the world on their own terms.[1] This distinction matters. Being autistic does not mean that every difficulty has to be accepted as an immutable feature of the self, and learning to function more effectively does not necessarily mean learning to hide who you are.


Social life as another academic subject


“I took the social life as seriously as I took my [university] course but unfortunately, I found that the social chemistry was quite a lot harder [than] the study of biomolecular forces when applied to enzyme kinetics.” (Segar)


For some autistic people, social life really can feel like another academic subject: something to observe, study, analyse and practice rather than something that simply happens intuitively. Being exposed to ‘mainstream life’ gives them the opportunity to learn (even by rote) and get at least theoretical information about the way the majority of people experience life:


Donna Williams described how being in mainstream environments exposed her to information about how people moved, spoke, behaved and responded to one another. Even when she could not immediately process what she was seeing, she accumulated information that could later become useful.


This is an important point. Learning social conventions is not necessarily the same thing as pretending to be someone else. It can be a way of acquiring information about a world that is otherwise difficult to interpret. The question, therefore, is not simply whether autistic people should be taught to “fit in”. The more useful questions are: What does this learning give the person access to? And what does it cost them?


Learning the rules – and building their own strategies

Many autistic people develop their own strategies for dealing with situations they find difficult. To avoid awkwardness in social interactions, they rely on previously learnt information (from their past experiences, books magazines, newspapers, TV programmes, etc.) that helps them to navigate social situations. Each person develops his/her own solutions. For example:


“I had learned that if I could think of nothing to say I could listen to the talk around me and seize on a word I recognized and start talking about it as a topic. I could tell what I knew, I could listen to what others knew, I could ask questions. I figured out that you could ask in different ways. One way so you got a yes or a no answer, which was uninteresting, therefore I was always pondering how to ask so the other person would have to explain what heshe knew. This caused me to end up in some strange conversations with people, and I thought it was great fun. Some thought I was batty and others that I was interesting, in any case it allowed me to be included.” (Johansson)


Donna Williams described learning ways of managing conversations when she could not understand what was happening: commenting on things around her, creating her own topic, talking about something she knew, or asking questions.


Temple Grandin described building up a “library” of past experiences, using what she had observed to work out which behaviours were likely to produce particular responses. She called this her “little scientist in the corner”: observing herself almost as though she were an outside researcher.


Some imitate people. To describe her ‘fitting in’ trick, Liane Holliday Willey (2014) coined the term sophisticated echolalia: this strategy (that is not easily detected by ‘outsiders’) helps them function in a social world they do not quite comprehend. They listen to the way others talk and learn what one should say and when. Autistic teenagers and adults can mimic their favourite characters in films, sitcoms and books as well.


Another approach that has been found beneficial is introducing rules of behaviours in different situations. Some autistic individuals in the absence of conventional rules may create their own and demand others to adhere to them, for example:


“Really Bad Things – Examples: murder, arson, stealing, destroying property, injuring or hitting other people…

Courtesy Rules – Examples: not cutting in on a line at the movie theatre or airports, table manners, saying thank you, and keeping oneself clean. These things are important because they make other people around you more comfortable. I don’t like it when somebody else has sloppy table manners, so I try to have decent table manners. It annoys me when other people cut in front of me in a line, so I don’t do this to other people.

Illegal But Not Bad – Examples: slight speeding on the highway and illegal parking…

Sins of the System (SOS) – Examples: smoking pot and being thrown in jail for ten years and sexual misbehaviour.” (Grandin)


All these and other strategies may look very different from spontaneous social interaction. But they can be remarkably effective. And they can become more sophisticated with experience.


Camouflage or compensation?

Knowing what to say, preparing topics of conversation, asking questions, learning social rules, consciously monitoring one's behaviour and imitating familiar social patterns can sometimes conceal difficulties from other people. In that sense, they may function as camouflage. But from the autistic person's perspective, they may primarily be tools for functioning. And again, that distinction matters: If every learned social strategy is automatically labelled “masking”, we risk creating another rather unhelpful binary: authentic autistic self versus artificial performance.


Human behaviour is rarely that simple. Learned behaviour can become genuine competence without necessarily becoming intuitive. A person may still have to think consciously about something that another person does automatically. That doesn't make the resulting behaviour fake. In fact, much of what human beings learn – from professional behaviour to driving, playing an instrument or speaking another language – eventually becomes easier through practice, without ever having been “natural” in the first place.


But aren't we just teaching autistic children to behave “normally”?

Teaching social conventions can certainly become pressure to conform. If a child is taught to reproduce ‘socially appropriate’ responses without necessarily understanding or identifying with them, social-skills training can become little more than rote performance and may resemble suppression of their natural ways of communicating and behaving.


But there is another possibility: Social conventions can function as tools for navigating a world in which autism is still poorly understood. Being able to recognise or use those conventions may reduce confusion, make relationships easier to initiate and sometimes protect a person from avoidable rejection. Because exclusion can itself have serious consequences.


So, the issue is not whether autistic people should learn social rules. It is how those rules are taught, what they are for, and whether the person has any choice about how to use them. A set of rules imposed from outside is one thing. Understanding the social environment well enough to make informed choices within it is something else.


Being understood

Quite a few autistic people express gratitude to their parents and teachers who have never made excuses for autism and have taught their autistic children to function in the ‘real world’ while providing adjustments and compensatory strategies to help them cope with their difficulties.  Naoki Higashida, a non-verbal autistic writer, expressed this particularly clearly when he described his mother's refusal to accept that communication should be good enough only for people who already understood autistic people:


“So, what has enabled my achievements? To my mind, a big part of it is that my mother never said to me, ‘Look, it’s good enough for the people who want to understand us: never mind about the rest.’ Whatever the obstacles that might spring up for us wholly or partially non-verbal people with autism, the ultimate goal is to keep honing our skills until we are understood by everyone. Everyone.”


That is a powerful aspiration. But it works both ways. The goal should not simply be to make autistic people easier for everyone else to understand. Other people also need to learn how autistic people communicate. Otherwise “communication skills” quietly becomes another name for “learning to communicate like us”.


Support does not mean doing everything for someone 

There is another practical issue here: the difference between support and overprotection.


I remember the first time I met Ros Blackburn, an autistic woman, in the early 2000s. She spoke very strongly about the importance of learning to function in the “real world” and about the damage that can be done when people make excuses for autism instead of providing opportunities to learn:


“Probably the most important and biggest reason, why I have done as well as I have done, is that no excuses whatsoever were made for autism. Making excuses for autism is so futile, so damaging and above all, so wasteful of learning opportunities… If I am to exist and get along in the real world, I will have to learn and obey the ways and conventions of the real world, whether I understand them or not. This may seem rather harsh and unfair on the person with autism, but reality is harsh and quite often unfair. Surely, it is even more unfair if parents, teachers, support workers, etc. do not prepare the person with autism for reality but shelter them from it” (Blackburn). 


I found her argument uncomfortable – and useful. At the time, I was overprotective of my twelve-year-old autistic son. Because of his motor difficulties and impulsivity, if he could not zip up his coat on the first attempt, he was likely to break the zip. So I always helped him. After hearing Ros speak, I decided to step back. I remained in the background but stopped immediately rescuing him (and the coat), whenever he asked for help, if I was confident that he could work out the problem himself. Three coats later, he could do it. He has had no problems with zips since.[2]


The lesson was not that autistic children should simply be left to struggle. It was that support does not necessarily mean doing something for somebody. Sometimes support means allowing them to discover that they can do it. There is a significant difference between removing an unnecessary obstacle and removing every opportunity to develop a skill. upport does not necessarily mean doing something for somebody. Sometimes support means allowing them to discover that they can do it.


On their own terms

One of the most interesting descriptions of learning to navigate the social world comes from Iris Johansson (2012), describing the relationship between an autistic girl and her father:


“Father had made up his mind that I had to choose this world. He wasn’t going to give up until he had made me understand there was something good, something exciting and fun in living in contact with other people… He couldn’t bear the thought of forcibly training me to see it but slowly nudge me towards it until my interest awakened. That’s how he got me to use the toilet, and that’s how he got me to eat, so he thought that it had to be possible to get me into the ordinary world also… [Father] wondered later with a shudder what would have happened if he actually had put me in an institution, or if he had followed the advice to leave me alone instead of struggling with me about everything. He understood that if he had stopped caring I would have sunk down in my state where no reasonable development took place, where my talents would have remained useless in reality… He was grateful that I was such a difficult enigma to solve, that I was so hard to figure out, because he learned what it was like to give up old concepts and think anew. He felt that he had developed greatly himself… …[T]he girl little by little actually was able to master the normal world, even if she did it in a complicated and unusual way, and [her father] became more and more pleased the more he noticed her developing on her own terms and making it OK.”


Not “normalising”, but opening doors

The purpose of teaching strategies is not necessarily to produce a person who looks indistinguishable from everyone else. It can be to increase the person's range of possibilities. A child who learns how to start a conversation has another way of entering social interaction. A person who learns how to recognise a particular social convention has another way of interpreting what is happening. Someone who learns how to regulate their own behaviour has another tool available when they need it. And someone who learns that they can solve a problem without immediate assistance has gained a little more independence. None of these things requires the person to stop being autistic.[3]


Some autistic people (especially with severe/profound autism) will need considerable support. Some will need explicit teaching of skills that other people acquire almost incidentally. Some will use conscious strategies throughout their lives. That does not automatically mean that they are living behind a mask. The useful distinction may be between hiding difficulties because other people demand it and learning strategies that give you more choices about how you live. The first can be exhausting and damaging. The second can be liberating.


“The worst thing you can do with a young autistic child is nothing” (Temple Grandin)


It is a deliberately provocative statement. But perhaps the useful question is not whether we should teach autistic people to become “normal”. It is whether we can give them more doors to open – and enough support to decide for themselves which ones they want to walk through.


It makes you think, doesn’t it?



______________________

[1] This is particularly relevant in the context of a growing strand of contemporary autism discourse in which autism is described as a form of “natural human variation”, and interventions intended to reduce difficulties may be rejected as attempts to change an individual’s “authentic self”, while environmental adjustments and services are nevertheless expected to accommodate those same difficulties.

[2] But he (now 38 years old) still doesn't know how to tie his shoelaces ☹ – I couldn't teach him, so I buy him shoes without laces. 😊

[3] The real issue is not whether autistic people should learn the rules of the social world. They will encounter that world whether we like it or not. The more difficult question is how we teach those rules without confusing conformity with development, obedience with understanding, or camouflage with identity.

Comments


Sign-up below for my monthly newsletter about my work, personal updates and 'Parent Corner' as well as blog updates.

Thanks for subscribing!

  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube

Copyright © 2021 OlgaBogdashina.com - All Rights Reserved.

Designed and built by Olesya Bath

bottom of page